Don't Play with Me Toys
Premium Toys & Collectibles for Serious Collectors
Why Collectors Choose Us
Rare Finds
Discover exclusive collectibles and hard-to-find toys that serious collectors seek out across the High Plains region.
Premium Quality
Every item is carefully curated and authenticated to ensure you're getting genuine, high-quality collectibles.
Local Expertise
Sterling's trusted toy and collectibles destination with deep knowledge of market trends and collector values.
About Don't Play with Me Toys
Located in the heart of downtown Sterling, Colorado, we're more than just a toy store – we're a destination for serious collectors and enthusiasts. Our carefully curated selection spans vintage classics to modern masterpieces, ensuring every visit brings new discoveries.
Visit Our Sterling Location
Location
216 Main Street
Sterling, Colorado
Store Hours
Sun-Mon: Closed
Tue-Sat: 10:30AM - 6:00PM
Contact
Call for current inventory
& special orders